On Permanence and Scars of Choice

The thing that gives me pause about getting a tattoo is all the awful things I would have gotten tattoos of earlier in life.

Think of photos of yourself in the 80s. Imagine if, somehow, that powder blue Don Johnson suit you loved, the one you wore with a white t-shirt and the sleeves rolled up, imagine if it never came off. It just stayed on your body, year after year, getting fuzzier. Tattoos are like that.

We all have tattoos already, of course. They’re our stories, our mental scars. The things we carry around with us, just under the surface. Your first breakup is always there, just around the corner in every relationship that comes after. Tattoos like this may not be seen, but they’re just as permanent.

The difference is, a tattoo is outward. It’s going to be seen, depending where it is, of course. At the very least, you’ll see it, and so will people you love. For some, it is quite literally wearing your heart on your sleeve. It’s a small sign to the universe that says, “This is me.”

Even if you have no intention of ever getting a tattoo, ask yourself, if you did, what would it be? How do you see yourself? What would be on your sign? It’s an amazing mental exercise.

Tattoos are even more complicated for my people. I have family members who had tattoos forced upon them. Their signs were a row of numbers on a forearm.

For many years, I said I couldn’t get a tattoo until my grandmother passed. She’s still with us, thank goodness, but her memory is shattered. Last time I saw her, she asked who’s son I was. If she saw me with a tattoo now, she’d forget a moment later.

When I met Heather, she had a few small tattoos. I thought they were hot. She always talked about getting more, and I was, to be honest, a little uptight about it.

Then we had the miscarriages. And I turned 35. And something changed in me. I could rationalize it as “taking control of our bodies” or some other hippy shit, but the truth is, I don’t know what changed. It’s still too recent.

My birthday present to Heather this year was a pair of tattoos. They’re amazing, and she’s not even done yet. Watching her go through the process of choosing her symbols, working with the artist, and committing them to her skin has been an inspiration.

I’m still scared of the permanence of it. But now I see it like this: Life is about collecting scars. Some of the scars are internal, some are external. Some you show to the world, some just to the ones you love. Some are forced upon you, and some you choose. It’s the collecting that’s important. If you don’t have scars, you’re not living.

I spent too many years avoiding risk, as if the goal was to leave a pristine corpse. Now I think, maybe it’s time to stop waiting. Stop avoiding. Go out there and get a scar to be proud of.

Our tattoos will be different. They will not be forced on us. They will not mean what they meant to my grandparents, or my parents. They will have a meaning that we create, and it’s okay if nobody else understands.

My first tattoo will begin this afternoon. It will be my sign to the universe. A scar of choice that I will wear on my sleeve. I still don’t know what it means, exactly, but I’ll have the rest of my life to figure it out.

And what is it? You’ll see. Soon.

+ + +

UPDATE: Please give a warm welcome to My New Friend.


Fray

18 Comments

Congratulations, and well said!

I, one with no tatoos at age 40, bave somehow recently become enamored with the idea of full sleeves. I think they’re really sexy, at least on hardbodied people in their youth. But if you’re going to do it, you might as well go full-hilt….

Maybe it’s too late for me to get in shape (it’s not); or maybe I just want to loose a few (25 or so) pounds before I muster up the dough and courage, but I haven’t yet taken the plunge.

When I do (and I will), it will be partially out of my recent shift in perspective, but it will also be partially your fault. Perhaps I’ll ask for it for my forty-first birthday….

Post a picture when you can — I’m sure we’d all love to see what handiwork you have laid against your body.

Posted by Michael Craig on 25 June 2008 @ 11pm

Congratulations, Derek. I hope you come to love your tattoo and let go of the apprehension. Though I guess you already have, as you’re making the leap!

I got a grim reaper on my right shoulder when I was 19 and playing guitar in a thrash band, and I’d have it again tomorrow. I’m 34 now and I haven’t had any more, but I still talk about it. Perhaps I will this year.

Would love to see yours when it’s done, man.

Peace,
–c.

Posted by clive on 26 June 2008 @ 12am

What a beautiful piece of writing. I really enjoyed this.

Posted by romanlily on 26 June 2008 @ 4am

I like this post Derek, but just remember, we can rationalize anything and everything and the smarter we are, the more crafty our rationalizations. Thank god I’m not very smart but I have a feeling you are.

I’ll be interested to see what you do (what the tattoo is) and your reflections post-tattoo.

My brain state and self image changes so rapidly and I’m just self-conscious and old enough (56) to avoid tattoos. I have plenty of the metaphoric type anyway, overflowing with them in fact. And I know my brain… post tattoo I’d perseverate the image change (okay, in my own head) to the point of insanity.

There was a Peanuts once: Lucy walks up to Charlie Brown and asks: “Charlie Brown, have you ever become aware of your tongue?”

The next frame has CB running and yelling…

Posted by Richard on 26 June 2008 @ 4am

I can’t think of a tattoo that would match, aesthetically, with the human body. To me, its like a doodle on the Venus de Milo.

Not to say they don’t look great on other people. Hope you love yours.

Posted by Paul D. Waite on 26 June 2008 @ 5am

Whooo Hoooo… Congrats… congrats!!!.. I’m hoping for a time-lapse movie.

Posted by Kevin-John on 26 June 2008 @ 6am

Great writing. I love your take on tattoos!

Posted by Travis Schmeisser on 26 June 2008 @ 6am

so well said, derek.

i can’t help but think of michael ondaatje, “we are communal histories, communal books. we are not owned or monogamous in our taste or experience. i wish for all of this to be marked on my body when i am dead.”

cheers to you this afternoon.

Posted by heatherdyan on 26 June 2008 @ 6am

To me, tats are (partially) an expression of a longing for permanence; the desire to have something in our lives finally figured out. I’ll never have one, because almost everything changes if you wait long enough.

The only symbol/image that I’d consider would be the name of my daughter. A father is the only thing I’ll always be.

Posted by Mike Gravel on 26 June 2008 @ 7am

Loved this post Derek. As someone who has tattoos both whimsical and meaningful, I appreciate the thought that’s gone into your decision, and your process to get here. Hope you love your new ink, and look forward to seeing it.

Posted by Mike on 26 June 2008 @ 7am

Interesting… can’t wait to see! We’re both still tattoo-free, though we’ve certainly thought about it. Just not convinced yet that we won’t regret it in the long run. Waiting for new technology that makes them less permanent. Really psyched to see you two all done, though!!

Posted by julie on 26 June 2008 @ 9am

Hi Derek,

From reading your posts over the years, I’ve gotten an impression that you are moderately religious. Given that, how do you feel about that fact with a tattoo, you cannot be buried in jewish cemetary? Or the fact that the religion prohibits desecrating your body in anyway… I ask, because I battled with the same thought (me being muslim) before totally covering up both my shoulders with tattoos of people I have lost over the years…. although – I am totally not religious, so I didn’t have to battle much :)

Posted by MR on 26 June 2008 @ 10am

I was sitting next to a man holding his daughter yesyerday.

“I want a tattoo, Daddy”
“No, no… I don’t like tattoos.”
“But your arms?” She was confused.
“Tattoos never go away. They tell about who you used to be and sometimes people change.”
The little girl traced a bird on his forearm “I think you used to be very beautiful.”

Good luck today. I hope it is everything you want and more.

Posted by kristyk on 26 June 2008 @ 1pm

Brilliant writing Derek, and I hope you share your ink with us when it’s done!

Posted by Andy Howard on 26 June 2008 @ 4pm

Life is about collecting scars. Some of the scars are internal, some are external. Some you show to the world, some just to the ones you love. Some are forced upon you, and some you choose. It’s the collecting that’s important. If you don’t have scars, you’re not living.
I actually have goosebumps — I think that’s one of the most brilliant paragraphs you’ve ever written. And that’s saying something.

Posted by myla on 26 June 2008 @ 10pm

How very “Tyler Durden” of you. I’ve always felt very similarly about tattoos. I’ve never really found an image that made me think, “Wow, I need to see that on my ass for the rest of my life.”, and I have also been fairly uptight about tattoos when it comes to seeing them on other people.

Some don’t bother me nearly as much. I’ve seen some people who have turned their bodies into a work of art. I personally don’t like the medium itself, but I certainly respect the art, the canvas and the cajones it takes to put your voice to any artist medium be it paint, words or skin.

It wasn’t until I read your equation of a tattoo to a scar that I realized I felt identically but had simply never been able to put it to those words. Tattoos are scars for people to collect. I think the thing that cheapens tattoos to me is that most scars are earned while tattoos are merely bought. There are people with tattoos all over their bodies that have simply been collected as so many post card or suitcase stickers, and they’re trying to pretend they’ve lived.

I’m thinking your new tattoo isn’t going to be as new a scar so much as it’s going to be newly visible. This is a well-written piece, and it definitely stands out. Good luck in your continued collecting.

Posted by joel on 27 June 2008 @ 4am

I wish some blogs had a “fav” option ala Twitter, Flickr, etc.. I’d favr this post.

Posted by Josh Bryant on 27 June 2008 @ 10am

I also like the idea of a tattoo that you don’t have a specific ‘what it means to you.’ You just know it speaks to you. Awesome choice. A nice big bold one for your first tattoo! :)

Posted by Zack Sheppard on 27 June 2008 @ 11am