Copyright is not evil
Just a thought from 26 February 2004 about .

Once again, I'm the curmudgeon. I think I'll have "bah humbug" etched on my tombstone.

Just for balance, I'd like to point out that I do, indeed, enjoy using a Creative Commons license for the Fray Audio, where the ownership is shared and the intent is noncommercial from the get-go. I'm a big supporter of what Creative Commons is trying to do.

But I'll never use a CC license for my photos, for example, because even their most restrictive license only "forces" people to attribute the work ("Photo by Derek Powazek"), use it noncommercially, and not alter it. By that logic, a religious right group could, say, take a photo like this and use it in some sort of awful anti-gay propaganda. Worse, the license would make sure my name was attached to it. No thanks.

I'm no copyright prude. I get what CC is trying to do, and I'm all in favor it. But I also still believe in traditional copyright law. It's there to protect artists. And, in the example above, protect the unspoken trust of people who I've photographed to use their images appropriately.

The thing to remember about traditional copyright is that it does just what it says: It protects an artist's right to copy the art they make. But the copyright holder can always, always, always allow others to copy their work with permission. So Cory can allow people to copy his books en masse, and I can choose to let some people use my photos and not others. That's our prerogative as the artists who made the work.

This section is called Just a Thought. It's a blog where I post little pieces of what I'm thinking about at the moment. This page is an individual entry called “Copyright is not evil” that I wrote on 26 February 2004.

Before this, I wrote a little something called “Three Things” on 26 February 2004. After this, I wrote “What he said” on 29 February 2004.

Three Things
This is where a post used to be. The post was probably ill-advised, definitely mean-spirited, and possibly also a little...
26 February 2004

What he said
Christopher Hitchens in Slate: "Now, as the dollars begin to flow from this front-loaded fruit-machine of cynical publicity, he is...
29 February 2004

The Fine Print

Working the web since 1995, Derek Powazek is the creator of many award-winning websites, a couple of which still exist. Derek is the cofounder of JPG Magazine and the CCO of 8020 Publishing. Derek lives in San Francisco with his wife, two nutty Chihuahuas, a grumpy cat, and a house full of plants named Fred. More »

Join the POWlist to receive the occasional note.


Thoughts by month:

Thoughts by subject:

Search with Technorati:

Search with Google:

In Print
My CaliforniaMy California
Contributor (Story)
We DoWe Do
Contributor (Photos)
Design for CommunityDesign for Community
Author (Tech)
San Francisco StoriesSan Francisco Stories
Author (Stories)
We've Got BlogWe've Got Blog
Contributor (Essay)